Kids Corner

Current Events

Our Narrative is Always Chardi Kalaa :
The Saga of Bhai Mani Singh





After a white supremacist opened fire at a Sikh gurdwara in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, USA, this past August, significant media resources have been devoted to describing, analyzing, and attempting to explain the event. A few of the prominent themes have included buzzwords such as "unprecedented," "victimization," and "suffering" endured by Sikhs in America.

Although these buzzwords rightfully point to the challenges faced by Sikh Americans, they fail to aptly capture the spirit and attitude with which Sikhs have embraced such challenges throughout history.

Traditionally the Sikh community does not lament periods of persecution and hardship, but instead, celebrates the contributions and sacrifices made by the community members and greater society living within those moments.

History offers a broad perspective for viewing this unique approach, and one instructive example is that of Bhai Mani Singh (d. 1737 CE), a prominent leader of the Sikh community in the early 18th century.

After a brief moment of political success in the early 18th century, the Sikhs quickly became targets of persecution. The ruling elite of India literally placed a price on the head of every Sikh, and official policies made it difficult (or from time to time, illegal) for Sikhs to assemble in public settings. Political oppression was particularly high in the 1730s when Bhai Mani Singh petitioned Governor Zakariya Khan to allow the Sikhs to gather in Amritsar for the purpose of community-building, social gathering, and decision-making. Khan agreed to the request with the stipulation that the Sikhs would pay the state a hefty tax in return.

Traditions recount that state authorities planned to let the Sikhs gather in Amritsar before unleashing a military strike that would decimate the community. Fortunately, Bhai Mani Singh caught wind of this plan and called off the gathering. In response to the state's fear-mongering and its oppressive practices, Bhai Mani Singh decided to make a statement. He publicly called out the government for reneging on its agreement and therefore refused to pay the taxes.

The state responded with a statement of its own. After arresting him, the authorities transported this community leader to Lahore and ordered that he be publicly executed in a most gruesome manner - dismembered, joint-by-joint. Traditions recount that the executioner sympathized with Bhai Mani Singh's plight and planned to spare him the torture by dismembering him limb by limb instead. However, Bhai Mani Singh looked up at his executioner and announced: "You don't need to feel sorry for me. Follow your orders and start the execution at my finger joints rather than my limbs."

To this day Sikhs do not grieve Bhai Mani Singh as a victim of oppression, but instead, they celebrate his contribution to the community and remember the price he paid in standing up for justice with the regularly repeated words: "bundh bundh kuttae (dismembered, joint-by-joint)."

The account of Bhai Mani Singh demonstrates the Sikh commitment to battle oppression, and his memory illustrates the Sikh spirit of celebrating those who have made sacrifices to stand against injustice. Sikhs do not remember him as a helpless victim, but as a heroic activist.

The recent narrative of Sikhs in America as victims is overly simplistic and incongruent with Sikh traditions.

It is time for us to revisit this victimization narrative and account for the Sikh spirit of chardi kala (perpetual optimism). This approach will help us better understand perspectives of the Sikh community, from the celebratory memories of Bhai Mani Singh to the positive responses following the hate-inspired massacre in Oak Creek.

Simran Jeet Singh is a doctoral candidate in religion at Columbia University.


[Courtesy: Journal Sentinel]

December 26, 2012


Conversation about this article

1: Baldev Singh (Bradford, United Kingdom), December 26, 2012, 9:23 PM.

The saga of an extraordinary sacrifice. Are we capable of such commitment, dedication, integrity and sacrifices today?

2: Bhai Harbans Lal (Dallas, Texas, USA), December 28, 2012, 10:40 AM.

Simran Jeet ji, you've brought out an aspect of Bhai Mani Singh's martyrdom in a fresh light. I fully agree and am often distressed that the recent narrative of Sikhs in Americas and rest of the Western world was evolving as Sikhs being victims and must struggle like victims. This is certainly overly simplistic and incongruent with Sikh traditions, as you have pointed out. In our history, we have never lived and presented ourselves as victims. We never sought the assistance of others because we are victims. We have always been, and continue to be defenders of the rights of others and we have always fought for justice for all. Then others fought for our rights due to respect for us and due to their duty to protect us. Others have respected our human rights.

Comment on "Our Narrative is Always Chardi Kalaa :
The Saga of Bhai Mani Singh "

To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.