Kids Corner

Daily Fix

Conclave

T. SHER SINGH

 

 

 

Spring is in the air. The snow is melting. The icicles are ebbing. The air can be taken in gulps again. 

Right on cue, my door bell rings one morning early this week … yes, it’s Ernie.

“Time for coffee?” he asks.

He’s a Catholic friend I’ve known ever since I moved to this village. Occasionally, we get together for a couple of hours over coffee and muffin, and review the goings-on in the world.

“You been following the papal circus?” he asks, as soon as we sit down in the café.

He knows of my interest. I think I may have impressed him once by bragging about the week I spent in the Vatican a dozen years ago, and the fact that I had even managed to meet John Paul II, albeit ever so briefly.

I nod and deftly throw the ball back in his court. It’s his Pope and I don’t want to offend him with an insensitive remark.

“Well,” he says, his Irish tongue-roll as musical as ever, “they disappointed us badly when they chose Benedict. And, as expected, he‘s disappointed us with all these wasted years. And now, finally, this inspired act …”

He pauses for effect …

“ … of abdication! The good Lord finally got through to him, didn’t He?”   

I’m still not ready to jump into the fray. I let him continue.

“So, will they disappoint us again, or will they try to save the sinking ship, eh? The million dollar question is, will they give us a John Paul, or will they saddle us with another Benedict.“

I grunt my approval of his assessment.

“So, what do YOU guys do,” he asks. “Do you go through the same bloody mess every few years too?”

Hm-mm-mm, I say to myself, I never thought of it that way. What DO we do?

The wheels in my head whir and whirl quickly, and I change focus. Strange, I’ve never given much thought to how we manage our own affairs, certainly not in this context.

Ernie’s staring at me, waiting for an answer. 

I explain to him that our situation in Sikhdom is somewhat different. To begin with, we have no priests, no clergy. No one stands in anyone’s shoes, Peter’s or Paul’s.

Yes, we do have leaders. Jathedars, we call them. Group leaders. They manage and oversee and manage the Five Takhts, the seats of authority. And there’s one who presides as the jathedar of the Akal Takht in Amritsar. From time to time, they address areas of concern or interest in the community, and then issue edicts. Which apply to Sikhs worldwide.

But since they are nowhere akin to a pope or hold any real religious authority, their selection process has attracted little attention. No one replaces our scripture. Yes, we do have a living leader: it is the Living Word. There’s no room for another.

Odd, I say to myself, but we as a community don’t do much, do we, to monitor or participate in selecting our petty jathedars, though.

I explain to Ernie that there’s a reason why. The selection used to be by the community until about 175 years ago. The Sarbat Khalsa fulfilled the role of ensuring that the best man was given the job.

Then, the British took over Punjab and usurped Sikh affairs, seeing merit in controlling the selection of the Sikh leadership. It was easier to meddle in Sikh affairs that way, and mess with them.

Ever since, off and on, we as a community get a good leader and then the state steps in and steers things away … and the community suffers. Grievously.

The process was inherited by the Indians when the British summarily jumped ship and a newly created India was left behind. Suddenly, a nation with a narrow-minded, short-sighted Hindu majority, and no interest in protecting minority interests, became the Goliath, and the miniscule 2% Sikh population was left with no power to wrest its destiny.

Ever since, and even today, our leaders are virtually hand-picked by a hostile government. A rag-tag band of ruffians belonging to another religion, if one can call it that. Invariably, they tend to select the worst and the weakest amongst us to ’lead’ us.

As a community, we seem to have thrown up our hands. Hence, there’s little public awareness of how our jathedars are actually selected -- the ‘democratic’ electoral aspect that may lead up to it is but a façade.

So, unless we have a revolution akin to the great Gurdwara Reform Movement of the 1920s -- and I briefly explain to Ernie what it was -- we will remain leaderless. And rudderless. Adrift in the sea, like Yann Martel’s and Ang Lee’s Pi, with predators pacing back and forth on the rocking boat, ready to pounce on us.

Ernie nods sympathetically.

“Remember, I’m Irish,” he says, “we’ve been through the same crap for centuries!”
 
We’ve emptied our coffee mugs by now, and get up for refills.

“But I’m not sure what’s worse,” Ernie begins, as we settle back in our seats, “you with your nation hijacked by the corrupt and the ignorant, or our religion at the hands of, well, 115 tired old men … dressed in bright red frocks and white lace and tons of gold and jewels … claiming their biggest qualification is that they haven’t ever had healthy sex … and spending their lives hiding those amongst them who habitually diddle pubescent boys and helpless women … imagine, they’re going to be choosing our next leader!”

I let my mind wander.

So, we’ve decided that our two respective religious communities are in crisis. How are the others doing?

I rack my brain and can’t think of a single religious leader of world stature.

Except, maybe, the Dalai Lama. And all he does is utter platitudes with the frequency and gravitas of fortune cookies.

Who else is around to save the world?

The ayatollahs and the mullahs who have distorted Islam to the point of no recognition as the great movement it began a millennium ago?

Or the rabbis who have made it their life-work to steal land from others, while spitting at their own women for wanting to find joy in life?

The evangelicals who live in crystal palaces and amass ill-gotten wealth, promising dividends in the hereafter?

The brahmins and their surrogates who freely rape, pillage and plunder, offering nothing but utter misery in return?

Yes, I say aloud, it’s nice to watch the pomp and splendour around the selection of a new Pope. But, surely, it’s but a reminder to all of us … Sikh, Christian, Buddhist, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu … that it is time to deep-six the very idea of religion, and come up with a better, brighter alternative.

Strange, but Ernie and I agree on this.

Having resolved the path the world needs to take hereon, we head home our separate ways. Ready to keep an eagle eye in the days ahead on the colour of the smoke wafting out of the Sistine’s copper chimney.

 

March 13, 2013

Conversation about this article

1: Sangat Singh (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia), March 13, 2013, 3:47 PM.

Election of a Pope and the eventual emanating of coloured smoke remains a colourful facade. For that matter, no religion is exempt; all are subject to human frailties, be it sexual indiscretions or something else. Not long ago there was a case of the Hindu high priest, Shankarachaarya Bramananda who was alleged to have been poisoned and there was a court case in Allahabad. Then, there are the politically motivated hukamnamas issued from time to time by the takhts, or the fight for kursis as recently demonstrated in the Delhi gurdwara elections.

2: Sarjit Kaur (Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, U.S.A.), March 13, 2013, 5:10 PM.

T Sher Singh jio, Guru Granth Sahib has been our leader after Guru Gobind Singh Ji! :)

3: Baldev Singh (Bradford, United Kingdom), March 13, 2013, 5:58 PM.

Lightning has struck twice today! I managed two articles on sikhchic.com, and I've enjoyed both of them very much. This one is to the point and every single Christian, Hindu, Jew, Buddhist, Muslim ... and Sikh! ... should read!

4: Sangat Singh (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia), March 14, 2013, 2:04 AM.

Since both Sher and Ernie had allowed the black smoke to emanate from the copper chimney to obviate taking any dire responsibility, and since the new Catholic Shankaracharaya has now been chosen, let's see how he navigates the boat. When the first Indian Adi Shankaracharya established the four Hindu centres and the four seats of shankracharaya, he also announced that everything was an illusion. One morning, as was his wont, he went for his ritual bath. As he was coming out a man touched him on purpose and told him: "Please forgive me, I am a sudra and an untouchable. I am sorry but looks like you will have a take another bath to purify yourself." The Shankaracharya was of course pontifically angry and announced that the untouchable would be punished in hell for what he had done. The man said, "When all is an illusion, it seems only hell remains real". That took Shankaracharya aback. The man continued and asked if the Shankaracharya would answer a couple of questions before going in for his second bayh. If not, he threatened, he would touch the high-priest again. The Shankaracharya had no choice and said: "What are your questions?" My first question: "Is my body an illusion? Is your body an illusion? And, if the two illusions touch each other, what is the problem? Looks like you are not practicing what you are preaching." They are still stuck with this question. Guru Nanak provided that answer - Go to any gurdwara and see for yourself ... having langar, you could very well be sitting next to a maharajah!

5: Simon (London, United Kingdom), March 14, 2013, 6:26 AM.

Interesting to note the difference: papal selection appears to be based on the adage, "older is wiser," whereas the Sikh Gurus were selected purely on their spiritual merits. Five under eighteen, 3 middle-age and only one in his latter years. Guru Angad 35. Guru Amar Das 73, Guru Ram Das 40, Guru Arjan 18, Guru Har Gobind 11, Guru Har Rai 14, Guru Har Krishan 5, Guru Tegh Bahadar 44, Guru Gobind Rai (later, Singh) 9. Are there any similarities in the roles and duties of the Pope versus the Sikh Gurus? Just to add, the Sikh Gurus are rarely depicted in their formative years in paintings/calendars, except, of course, Guru Har Krishan.

6: Harpal Singh (Sydney, Australia), March 14, 2013, 6:32 AM.

A good read ... easy + relaxing. Great write-up.

7: Kulwant Singh (U.S.A.), March 14, 2013, 7:56 AM.

Organized religion is bound to fail because it is more concerned with managing a flock, rather than attaining salvation. No religious leader, pope or otherwise, can grant you liberation. You have to put in the work yourself. Guru Nanak made his stance against organized religion when he stated "There is no Hindu and no Muslim". There is only one God and one family of people.

8: Kanwarjeet Singh (USA), March 14, 2013, 5:27 PM.

I am surprised you did not simply direct him to the Daily Fix article you recently wrote, titled 'No Brokers, Please'. Sikhi is simple - there is a living Guru, there are no pilgrimages or historical sites we need to go to, to cleanse ourselves, or leaders we need to go to, to pray for us (prey on us - depending on how you look at it). Remember Waheguru, thank Him for what you have and do your kirat and make sure no one else is in suffering. What could be simpler? Though, in the past 3 to 4 decades we have made it more complex for ourselves.

Comment on "Conclave"









To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.