Kids Corner

Current Events

Hate Hits Home:
Columbia University Sikh-American Professor Attacked in Hate Crime -
Dr Prabhjot Singh

PAUL BRANDEIS RAUSHENBUSH & SIMRAN JEET SINGH

 

 

 


A Columbia University professor was assaulted on Saturday night in what police say is being investigated as a hate crime.

According to a New York Police Department source, Dr. Prabhjot Singh, who is a Sikh-American and wears a turban and a beard, was attacked at 8:15 p.m. while walking along 110th Street near Lennox Avenue in upper Manhattan. An unknown suspect or suspects shouted anti-Muslim statements, knocked the professor down and punched him numerous times in the face.

[The New York Daily News describes the assailants as a mob of 25 to 30 men.]
 
Simran Jeet Singh, a student and friend of Dr. Prabhjot Singh, visited the victim at Mt. Sinai Hospital where he is recovering from several severe but non-life-threatening injuries.

According to Simran Jeet Singh, Prabhjot said that during the attack the assailants shouted "get Osama" and "terrorist."

Prabhjot is a practicing doctor in East Harlem as well as an assistant professor of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University. He and Simran Jeet Singh wrote about the importance of gathering more information on hate crimes against Sikhs in an op-ed in the New York Times last year:

The government must begin tracking and counting anti-Sikh hate crimes, just as it must continue to vigorously combat bias and discrimination against all Americans, including Muslims.”




WHEN MY FRIEND BECOMES A TARGET
Simran Jeet Singh

Last night, I received the kind of phone call that everyone dreads: a close friend was hurt, and was on his way to the hospital.

But the news got worse as I learned that my friend, Dr. Prabhjot Singh, a young Sikh American professor at Columbia University, had been brutally attacked on a public street, the victim of a violent hate crime. My brother and I immediately jumped in a taxi and rushed to the hospital where we finally saw Prabhjot being wheeled in, bloody and bruised, his face swollen from a fractured jaw. He couldn't speak because many of his teeth had been displaced, but he waved limply to let us know that he was okay.

We joined Prabhjot in his hospital room and were surprised to find it already filled with officers from the NYPD and its Hate Crime Task Force. As he struggled to give his statement, we came to learn that his assailants had taunted him as they beat him, calling him "Osama" and "terrorist." He described being punched in the face repeatedly until falling to the ground. And then he recalled how the punches to the head continued as he laid on the sidewalk.

I saw Prabhjot shudder as he realized how much worse it could have been. He had just returned from dinner, dropping his wife and one-year-old son at home before going for a walk. He reached from his hospital bed and grabbed his wife's hand.

He recounted the scariest moment, seeing a young male put his arm inside his coat, as if reaching for a gun. He also remembered people pulling at his long beard. He couldn't provide any descriptions about his assailants, and it seemed to me that in some way, he didn't want to remember them.

Prabhjot has dedicated his life to serving the underserved.

He is currently the Director of Systems Management at the Earth Institute, and he draws upon his experiences abroad to help improve the health of local communities like Harlem.

In addition to serving as an Assistant Professor at Columbia University's School of International and Public Affairs, he is also a resident physician at Mt. Sinai Hospital. His life's work has been to help the underprivileged access quality and affordable healthcare, and he believes strongly that his countless hours of service are an investment in improving the health of impoverished communities.

Unfortunately, his assailants did not see Prabhjot Singh, the professor, the community health expert or the local doctor. They saw a man wearing a beard and a turban -- his articles of faith -- and saw a target.

Sadly, for many other Sikh-Americans like Prabhjot, this is a story they have heard and experienced before.

This past May an elderly Sikh gentleman was brutally beaten with a steel pipe in Fresno, California, and in March a Sikh male was shot while driving just outside of Orlando, Florida. And as we all know, in August 2012 a white supremacist entered a Sikh place of worship (gurdwara) in Oak Creek, Wisconsin and opened fire on the congregation, killing six worshippers.

Sikh-Americans have repeatedly been targeted in hate violence throughout the country, and we believe that much of this stems from a dangerous combination of hate and ignorance. Many perpetrators of hate violence are unable to see the humanity of their victims.

It seems that Prabhjot's assailants associated his turban and beard with Osama bin Laden and terrorism. This observation is consistent with a national study released by Stanford University researchers less than two weeks ago, which shows that more than 50 percent of Americans associate the Sikh turban with Osama bin Laden -- more than with any other figure.

In today's America, so many of us can be perceived as different. Whether it is our religion, our racial or ethnic background, our sexual orientation, or our gender identity, all of us are potentially someone's "other," and can be discriminated, excluded, or even targeted for violence because of it.

In light of this incident, and all those that have come before, it is increasingly clear that we, the "others," need to build bridges with one another, and with the community at large. We will make the hate and violence stop. We absolutely have to.

 

Please CLICK here to view a TED Lecture by Dr Prabhjot Singh.

[Courtesy: The Huffington Post. Rev. Paul Brandeis Raushenbush is the Senior Religion Editor of The Huffington Post. Simran Jeet Singh is a doctoral candidate in Religion, Columbia University, New York. Kiran Kaur and Justin Collins contributed to the article by Simran Jeet Singh. Edited for sikhchic.com.]

September 23, 2013
 

Conversation about this article

1: AngloSikhPeace (Nottingham, England), September 23, 2013, 5:46 AM.

I hope Prabhjot Singh gets well soon, it is always painful when we hear that one of Maharaj's Gursikhs has suffered so horribly.

2: Himmat Singh (Chandigarh, Punjab), September 23, 2013, 7:11 AM.

Our prayers are with Prabhjot and his family.

3: Devinder Pal Singh (Delhi, India), September 23, 2013, 7:34 AM.

We wish and pray for Dr. Prabhjot Singh's speedy recovery and good health. Hating anyone is inadmissible and civilized people should refrain from such acts. In modern society, with all the education available, it should become a priority to eradicate this evil. I sincerely hope that the American Society rises to this demand and just as they got rid of slavery in their country so would they be able to bury the violence unleashed by hate by erasing this word from their dictionary. It'll become the role model in the world and quickly put my own country to shame and embarrass them into doing something about their own virulent epidemic.

4: Gurmeet Kaur (Atlanta, Georgia, USA), September 23, 2013, 9:10 AM.

It is upsetting at multiple levels. Columbia University is home to several brilliant Sikh activists that educate the mainstream community of our existence by leading a public life of service along with their educational goals - most of them aligned towards making this world a better place. Prabhjot is a shining star and role model amongst them. He and his wife choose to live in Harlem not too far from CU to work among the under privileged; to improve their health. Last year when Angad Singh, my son joined these amazing gursikhs in his educational pursuit at Columbia, we had a conversation about Prabhjot's decision to live in Harlem and serve. With Harlem's reputation, I expressed my worries, but Prabhjot seemed larger than life defending his community at Harlem and not a least bit concerned about his safety. In fact, his eyes lit up when he mentioned about the numerous times that people recognize him for his work and the respect he gets walking those streets. It is upsetting that a father of a one-year old would get beat up by a mob in Manhattan. Even with such service and activism - not much has changed for us. Is it not time to reassess our direction in tackling these hate crimes? Until when will Sikhs keep becoming a collateral damage in America's war against Islam?

5: Baldev Singh (Bradford, United Kingdom), September 23, 2013, 9:25 AM.

Unless we stop wrongly calling ourselves 'South Asians', 'Asians' or even 'Indians', then how on earth are the world's 7,000,000,000 non-Sikhs going to find out who we really are?

6: Baljit Kaur (Utah, USA), September 23, 2013, 9:56 AM.

Until and unless we -- as individuals and as a collective -- are willing to sacrifice part of our resources and pool them for the larger good, we -- our children, our loved ones, our friends, our colleagues, and yes, we ourselves -- will continue to pay a heavy price for the continuing ignorance of others. Again ... yes, yet again ... this is NOT the time for platitudes. Remember, we are the most under-serviced minority on the planet. The fault lies not in the stars, and not with our enemies and detractors (of which indeed there many, but no more than our fair share), but in ourselves! Period. What're we going to do about it? Each one of us has to answer this from within ourselves ... and for ourselves. If not ... look at the title of this article. "Hate Hits Home"! If we don't do anything NOW ... TODAY ... then, inevitably, the chickens will come home (OUR home!) to roost one day ... In the meantime, though, May Waheguru bless Prabhjot and his family ... I pray he and his loved ones recover from this outrage quickly.

7: Gurmeet Kaur (Atlanta, Georgia, USA), September 23, 2013, 10:03 AM.

Please tune in at Huffington Post Live now (10:15 AM EST) at http://live.huffingtonpost.com/ to hear Prabhjot Singh.

8: Pardeep Singh Nagra (Toronto, Ontario, Canada), September 23, 2013, 10:42 AM.

I visted New York with my family just a month ago and was priviledged to stay with Dr. Prabhjot Singh and his family Manmeet Kaur and young Hukam Singh. They are proud Sikhs and even prouder Americans serving their community. I just finished listening to Prabhjot speak live right now on Huffington Post. He is a true ambassador, steadfast in his commitment to his faith, his community and his country. Our thoughts and prayers are with him and his family.

9: Onkar Kaur (Los Angeles, California, USA), September 23, 2013, 12:13 PM.

Sikhi teaches us to turn our sadness and anger -- both of which all of feel now, so strongly -- into something constructive ... into action that leads to some good. Let's concentrate on that, while we pray for Prabhjot and his early recovery.

10: Ajmer Singh (London, United Kingdom), September 23, 2013, 1:01 PM.

"Jinaa Singhaa(n) Singhneeyaa(n) ne ... dharam nahi(n) haarya, Sikhi kesaa(n} swasaa(n) naal nibahee, tinaa di kamayi da dhyan dhar ke ... bolo ji ... Waheguru!"

11: G Singh (United Kingdom), September 23, 2013, 3:36 PM.

Unless and until a spectacular glossy leaflet about the Sikh Americans, depicting role models and other information about Sikhi, is delivered to each and every household in America, we won't get anywhere. It may cost a million dollars but it's better than building yet another gurdwara.

12: Kanwal Prakash Singh (Indianapolis, Indiana, USA), September 23, 2013, 4:31 PM.

The attack on Dr. Prabhjot Singh is another reminder of continuing hostility, unfounded stereotyping, unprovoked violence, verbal assaults, mistaken-identity episodes, and hate crimes against innocent Sikhs on the streets, public parks, neighborhoods, and Sikh places of worship. Education, advocacy, civic engagement, and working with law enforcement and faith leaders is the first major step to dispel ignorance and stem the culture of violence and to create an environment of understanding about people, faiths, and cultures. Everyone deserve the right to live, work and serve our country in safety. What could be more sacred than that. Prabhjot and his parents, Dr. and Sardarni Tarlochan Singh of Indianapolis, set a fine example of dedication to work, service to the community and humanity for all of us.

13: Gurteg Singh (New York, USA), September 23, 2013, 9:53 PM.

Although hate crimes against any group, including Muslims, must be condemned, what prevents our civil rights organizations like Sikh Coalition and SALDEF in speaking the truth why Sikhs are being targeted after 9/11? Whenever the anchors/guests on major media outlets have suggested that Sikhs are being targeted because of mistaken identity, the answer is evasive or perhaps we can call diplomatic or politically correct but never the truth. The truth of the matter is that we are target of hate crimes almost 100% of the time because people consider us Muslims and associate us with terrorist master-mind Osama bin Laden, Taliban leaders or Iranian Mullahs or other fundamentalists from the Middle East, especially those who also don turban and beard. Sikh Coalition's Sapreet Kaur was an exclusive guest on June 27, 2013 with Lauren Green on Fox News to discuss the FBI's decision on tracking hate crimes against Sikhs. The anchor pointedly asked her twice whether you are being targeted because you are confused as Muslims. But Sapreet Kaur would not say the obvious which Sikhs actually experience every single day. Here is the dialogue between the two at the fag end of the interview: Anchor Lauren Green: "There is a lot of data about hate crimes against Muslims after 9/11. There is a lot of hate against Islam because they blame all Muslims for what the terrorists had done, and that I bring up this idea, 'Are we confusing Muslims for Sikhs" ... if it had not been for 9/11, if it had not been other terrorist activities perpetrated by Muslims, perhaps this would not be happening (to Sikhs)." Sapreet Kaur was very emphatic in her reply: - "I don't think we could say that in absolute terms AT ALL ... I definitely think it may be part of the targeted bigotry, but it is ABSOLUTELY NOT SO EXCLUSIVELY."

14: Raj (Canada), September 23, 2013, 10:50 PM.

Every Sikh household in the US has at least two cars. Start educating the American public by putting bumper sticker that says, "Sikh prayer: I'm not HINDU, I'm not MUSLIM". That's a simple and but powerful beginning. First of all, the quote is in our gurbani, "na hum hindu na musalman / alho ram ke pind pran". Every gurdwara should make arrangements to provide these stickers free of cost. Second, by driving around you are educating people inadvertently about Sikhs. Third, try to avoid secluded places alone, always have someone with you. You have to remember, your safety is in your own hands. Especially, when you know an average American is an unintelligent, ignorant, violence loving character.

15: Sunny Grewal (Abbotsford, British Columbia, Canada), September 23, 2013, 11:55 PM.

@13 Gurteg Singh: I agree with your observation that when given the proper platforms our representatives are skirting around the main issue. Sikhs are being targeted as Muslims, that is the bottom line. The beard and turban unfortunately fulfill the stereotypical image of the Muslims who are being identified as terrorists. We need to stop wasting the few opportunities our community gets in the media with political correctness. The Muslim population of the United States is much larger than Sikhs, they have more resources and manpower to represent their own interests. We should be focused on using our available resources to help our own community.

16: Sid (India), September 24, 2013, 2:36 AM.

Have written a piece: "Obama - Get to know your Sikhs, Please" (on notesfromsid.blogspot.in). It's for the Sanatanites to stand up for the Sikhs.

17: SSN (USA), September 24, 2013, 1:27 PM.

Re posts #13,#14 and #15: Political correctness by Sikh organizations is probably the biggest disservice they are doing. I followed the news coverage following Oak Creek tragedy - every Sikh interviewed failed to say anything about being a Sikh, there was no mention of being confused with Muslims. Are we so wired to be politically correct all the time that we end jeopardizing the community and our future? Sikhs and mistaken identity isn't a new problem, is it? A World War II photograph printed during that time describes us as Hindus. I'm actually getting really tired of Sikhs and the Sikh media going around showing their "big" heart and inadvertently causing bigger harm to the community.

18: Hargurmit Singh (Delhi, India), September 25, 2013, 1:20 AM.

Veer Prabhjot Singh ji, we all pray for your speedy recovery and hope you remain forever safe to carry on your mission of educating others about Sikhi. While on this path, let me share with you Bhagat Kabir ji's shabad - "Kabir kasatooe raam ki jhoottha tikeah naa koeay / raam kasatooe so sahieay jo maar jeevarah hoeay" [GGS:948]. As you walk on the path you have chosen you will be tested and maybe even tested repeatedly by Waheguru, but with His grace you will pass these tests and be the beacon for all others who will follow. May Waheguru keep you in chardi kala.

19: RSB (United Kingdom), September 26, 2013, 4:37 AM.

It is appalling that even in 2013 there are so many ignorant people in the world who still have a lack of understanding about the differences between a Sihh and a Muslim. Sikhs have played a vital and positive role within Western society for well over a century. We must educate these people about our great Faith.

Comment on "Hate Hits Home:
Columbia University Sikh-American Professor Attacked in Hate Crime -
Dr Prabhjot Singh "









To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.