Kids Corner

1984

Lost No More:
I Remember 1984

BHUPINDER SINGH MAHAL

 

 

 

The June 1984 attack by the Indian government troops on Harmandar Sahib so lacerated the psyche of the Sikh people that even an iconoclast like Khushwant Singh was driven to returning his Padma Bhushan award, the high civilian honour bestowed on him in 1974.

In my own case, the trauma of the assault on Sikhdom's holy of holies, if measured on the Richter scale, was magnitude 6.0, compared to my outrage at the massacre of innocent Sikhs in India’s major cities, towns and villages that began on November 1, 1984, which measured 8.0 or higher.

The dastardly pogrom unleashed against the Sikhs was to engender a paradigm shift in my politico-religious thinking.

As I, who had until then lived a life in a self-induced cultural and religious vacuum, watched TV coverage of the murder, looting and torching of Sikh homes, my faith in the good-heartedness of humans was dashed, evoking a long, quiet introspection.

My soul-searching led to a politico-religious awakening and comfort with my faith, culture and heritage giving credence to the old Urdu sayng: "subhaa ka bhoola agar shaam ko ghar aa-ye to usay bhoola nahi kehtay" - "The lost one who returns home at the end of the day is lost no more!

To appreciate my metamorphosis, I must first rewind the reel of my life and replay it from the beginning.

I was born in Uganda but grew up in Kenya, mostly in Nairobi.

My mother was a devout Sikh. She proud possession was a nitnem gutka (breviary), wrapped in linen cloth, which she would uncover to recite her prayers in the early hours of dawn, at dusk, and again just before retiring. She would sit me in her lap and tell mesmerizing tales from the janamsakhis and, as I grew older, she would sit me by her side and sing the song of Sikhism.

On Sundays she took my siblings and I to the gurdwara.

My father was less passionate about his faith. In appearance, he was the Sikh of the Guru. He wore the five kakkaars. He did not wear the kirpan per se but had a miniature simulacrum embedded in his kangha that he anchored in the joorrah of his hair before tying his turban.

The infighting that split the Nairobi congregation along clannish loyalties so disenchanted him that he rarely went to the gurdwara.

From childhood, I never grew long hair because of chronic scalp infections. In my teens the virus was gone and my mother began imploring me to grow my hair and stop going to the barber. My father was neutral to the idea. Growing hair long had lost appeal as all my school friends were shaven.

I became estranged from my family soon after matriculation. At the time I possessed only a rudimentary understanding about my faith. I journeyed as a nomad, moving from country to country, continent to continent.

In the early 1950’s, I made my home in England. At the time, the only known gurdwara in my vicinity was located in Shepherd Bush, London, and was far from my flat in Belsize Park. I emember visiting the gurdwara just on two occasions during my eight years in London.

Among a handful of friends of mine, mostly English, the only other Sikh was like me. Cultural or religious exchanges were rare. It was no surprise that my malleable mind of a liberal began to be forged in the crucible of my environment, resulting in an inevitable seepage of religious values which were supplanted by secular ideas and attitudes.

In the winter of 1961, I was recruited by a British conglomerate as a senior executive for overseas posting in British Guiana (now Guyana). The country is populated by descendants of indentured labour, principally from the eastern seaboard of India, brought in to work in the sugar plantations in the West Indies following the slave emancipation in 1838.

Though the name ‘Singh’ is fairly common in Guyana and Trinidad, people bearing the name on the island had no religious affiliation to Sikhs -- they were Hindus from Bihar and the United Provinces (now Uttar Pradesh) . Hence, there was no gurdwara around.

I was the only Sikh in the country; one of four Punjabis. One of the Punjabis was a priest hired by an Arya Samaj (a Hindu sect) mandir while the other two were there, lured by business opportunities.

In 1963, I was to marry a local girl, who though of East Indian descent, belonged to the Muslim faith. Her guardian-brother was firm on holding a nikah (Muslim ceremony) at his home and was not averse to a parallel ceremony performed in another faith. My Punjabi priest friend offered to solemnize our marriage under Vedic rites.

This was the first time since leaving Kenya that I faced a religious quandary. As I faced crossing the religious Rubicon, the song of Sikhism that I listened at my mother’s knee echoed in my mind. I explained my religious dilemma to my wife to be, who, at risk of falling-out with her guardian and family members, agreed to a civil marriage.

Consequentrly, she became a persona non grata with her family, and some months later out of her own volition changed her name by deed poll.

Our daughter was born in Georgetown. Her birth is first ever to register the name ‘Kaur’, a prerequisite for a Sikh female, and we stipulated “Sikh” in the box marked "RELIGION".

In 1967, we relocated to Canada. After spending a few years in Ontario, we moved and made our home on the outskirts, west of Montréal. We made new friends. Among them were two Sikh families, one Muslim family, a Muslim bachelor and several Hindu families. There was also a wider circle of diverse acquaintances.

In the early 1980’s, a bunch of us started a ‘puploo’ school (a variation of the card game, Rummy), convening once a month on a rotational basis. I was the sole Sikh player making up the group of five.

In mid-June 1984, the game was scheduled at the home of a Muslim host. As we sat down at the card table, a Hindu player remarked about the assault on the Golden Temple. His words, I felt, were pregnant with double entendre. As I mulled over a riposte, our host pleaded that politics be left at the door and put an end to any further comment.

Frankly, I doubt I had an articulate rejoinder. At the time, I was outraged by the assault on the Golden Temple and at the same time, influenced by the press coverage from India, I was equally troubled by what I felt then was an unwarranted occupation of the Akal Takht by Bhindranwale and his supporters. On occasion, at a social gathering, for example, Hindu friends and acquaintances goosed the Sikhs to comment on the assassination of Indira Gandhi, the idea of Khalistan and what they termed as Sikh-upon-Hindu violence, as a way of questioning Sikh loyalty and placing all the guilt on the Sikh community.

Some Sikhs, sadly -- outnumbered -- sang from the same hymn page as the Hindus. I stayed mute.

The socio-political status quo remained unchanged until Saturday, November 3, 1984, when two of the calls that I received on that day were to cause a paradigm shift in my thinking.

The first call was from the wife of a very close Hindu friend, trying to allay my anguish at the killings of Sikhs in Delhi by imputing the killings to “taangewalas” (hansom cab drivers), a metaphor for poverty-stricken, low-caste people hankering for mischief.

She meant well but blithely ignored reality on the ground showing unmistakable images of prominent politicians quarterbacking a mob in the resettlement colonies, Trilokpuri in particular, to systematically kill, rape, loot and torch Sikh homes.

The second caller was my brother-in-law living in Sarnia (Ontrio, Canada). We talked of the massacre, the provocative slogans such as  “khoon ka badla khoon” ("blood for blood!") heard from the mobs in India, government inaction to deploy the army to stop the killing and failure of Hindu friends to commiserate with their Sikh friends who may have lost relatives.

Reminding me of my brief stint as court reporter for “The Daily Chronicle” (Nairobi) and freelance contributor to “The Current”, the Bombay weekly newspaper founded by D. F. Karaka, my brother-in-law urged me to take up the cudgels to inform the Canadian public of the unvarnished truth about the goings-on in Punjab.

A few days later, the first of my several letters to the Editor of the Montreal Gazette and the Globe & Mail was published.

I quickly learned that the Hindu community was outraged by my letter.How dare I challenge the official Indian story?

As subsequent letters got published, the ire of the Hindus multiplied and their blind indignation was manifested in the social ostracism of my family and I.

Thus began my journey to reclaim my culture, religion and heritage.

Conversation about this article

1: Parminder Kaur Dhillon (Raleigh, North Carolina, United States), October 30, 2012, 10:31 AM.

No one is lost for ever! Sometimes finding ourselves is learnt the hard way! One's consciousness has to be pricked enough to change one's thinking. But it is a journey each one of us must take on our own!

2: Chintan Singh (San Jose, California, USA), October 30, 2012, 11:34 AM.

Bhupinder ji: I and I'm sure other readers on this forum would be very interested in reading your journey from November 84 until now, of reclaiming your heritage and religion. What has been the reaction of your family, Sikh and non-Sikh friends? How has the local community welcomed, or not welcomed, you? Where and what have your learnings been of gurbani, Sikh history, current situation of the community, etc? Please do write a Part II of this powerful piece.

3: Harpreet Singh (Delhi, India), October 30, 2012, 3:15 PM.

Those were horrible days. Though many biased, mischievous elements are always there everywhere, then also we are always thankful to good non-Sikh persons like Assistant Sub-Inspector Jufti Ram of Delhi Police of the trans-Yamuna police station, advocate Bajrang Singh of North Delhi (who saved and helped thousands of Sikh families on his own), as also a large number of such persons known and unknown - journalists, media persons, retired judges, etc. who really helped a lot in spite of mischievous rumours spread against Sikhs; even our neighbours in whose home we stayed for seven days as welcome guests. In my opinion, without the help of such good people, the casualty figures would've been much higher, taking into account the enormity, preparedness and cruelty of the politician-led mobs let loose on Sikhs as also deliberate non-action on part of government authorities and police to save the innocent victims. However, we have totally failed to tell the world the facts. In the end, as per gurbani, we are all accountable for our actions even if we escape from worldly courts ("maanso keo debano koyi nas bhaj nikle / har deebano koyi kithe jaya" And - "jaikar kio dharmia ka / paapi ko dhand diyoye".

4: Harpreet Singh (Delhi, India), October 30, 2012, 3:37 PM.

One more weakness on our part: We are totally failing in PR, as well as in obeying the teachings of the Gurus. Criminal display of wealth in all our functions, sometimes in religious ones also (on part of those Sikh families too who cannot spare money for the same but somehow they will manage this); not only total absence of true humility, love, kindness in gurdwaras as well as our homes. So much politics, greed for power and position by those claiming to be leaders; total absence of any solid support system for the poor or the financially weak. Though, I should add, there ARE some Sikh individuals and bodies engaged in true service.

5: Ari Singh (Sofia, Bulgaria), October 30, 2012, 7:11 PM.

The year 1984 is fresh in my mind. I was interviewed on national Icelandic TV. There was a hindu doctor there as well and the public was curious to know if there was any tension between us. I was perhaps the only Sikh there then. We conveyed the message that everything was normal between us as we were both Icelandic nationals. But the Indian ambassador to Norway, Mr Anand, a Punjabi Hindu was quite bitter. There are good hindus and bad ones, just like in every community.

6: Devinder Pal Singh (Delhi, India), October 31, 2012, 7:30 AM.

Often the common man on the street questions his fellow Sikh brethren: 'why do you support Congress after what happened in 1984?' Alas, we have a very learned Prime Minister who has bowed every year of his Prime Minister-ship to the deity Indra and there are many more that would continue to do so to enjoy just a spoonful. This is one act that is never forgotten by those that suffered and it is one act that those seeking power do not like to comment upon. The Law in India is blind -- but not for the reasons it should be -- and hence there has been no deliverance, but above all the morality has been lost and all lines have been erased to enjoy power and self elevation. Sikhs need to realize the gravity and must exhibit their rejection of the double standards of delivering justice in India. While Indira's alleged executioners where hanged super quick, there has been no justice for the innocents who perished in 1984. Indians can repeat 'let's forget and move on' -- but ain't gonna happen.

7: Charandeep Singh (Chandigarh, Punjab), October 31, 2012, 1:55 PM.

I share the anguish of my fellow contributors. While I agree that the common non-Sikh man on the road should not be blamed for 1984 as it was the outcome of petty politics, I am in total consonance with the view of Harpreet Singh ji that we should make our PR strong. We do need to tell the world about us, our roots and our values. I am thankful from the bottom of my heart to the brave and principled non-Sikhs who extended a helping hand to our brothers and sisters in the hour of need and pray to the Almighty that our so-called 'leaders' start doing something for the community. I am again concluding my comment with the lines - "Shah Muhammada ik sarkar bajhon, faujan jitt ke vi ant nu haarian ne" - 'O Shah Muhammad, but for the lack of their leader (here, Maharaja Ranjit Singh), the forces lost the battle even when they had victory in their grasp!"

8: M.K.S. (New York City, USA), October 31, 2012, 5:02 PM.

I for one am not going to let the average Hindu in India off the hook for the 1984 pogrom that easily. I have two simple requests to the Hindu in India: 1) Petition your government to declare a day in June or Nov in remembrance of the massacre around Operation BlueStar and the anti-Sikh pogroms. (2) Since Hindus make 83% of India's population, if they stay at home just 1 day in support of the Sikhs, it would send such a powerful message to the Government of India, nothing then would stand in the way of justice for the victims of the 1984 massacres. Until this happens, I hold all Hindus in India, at the very least, indirectly complicit in the denial of justice to the Sikhs of India.

9: Jaspreet (Canada), October 31, 2012, 9:07 PM.

I went to India in 1985, and visited a gurdwara in Bhatiala. Some elderly men talked to my parents. They told them that while Harmandar Sahib was being attacked, the army also came here. These men had been tied up and were beaten by soldiers. Others, younger people did not fare so well. They were shot. The army took a truck load of people they shot. Please remember, Harmandar Sahib was not the only focal point of the wide-spread, orchestrated assault on Sikhs. 38 other Gurdwaras, major ones, were also attacked and truck loads of civilians killed and taken goodness knows where -- all on Guru Arjan's Shaheedi Day when we know the attendance of pilgrims goes up many-fold.

10: Charandeep Singh (Chandigarh/Punjab), November 01, 2012, 12:09 AM.

MKS ji: while your point is valid, what would you say about our so-called 'leaders'? It is said that the axe which chops wood itself has a wooden handle. When they cannot come together, how can we expect non-Sikhs to raise their voices for the community?

11: Roop Dhillon (Reigate, United Kingdom), November 01, 2012, 9:22 PM.

I feel for you.

Comment on "Lost No More:
I Remember 1984"









To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.