Kids Corner

People

Cri de Coeur:
A Cry From The Heart

by A. KAUR

 

 

 

The word pierces through my heart and shatters it to a million pieces. Pieces that will never be a part of the whole again.

The finality of the word, the sheer permanence of it, is hard to contemplate.

Recently, I told my husband that I did not see a future with him and that divorce (the dreaded word) was a more likely scenario.

Not easy words to come by, but this story has been unraveling, often spinning out of control, for a long time, ever since my in-laws began living with us, having arrived from India.

It hadn't always been this way. My husband and I had got along fine until then, with the occasional tit-for-tat that is typical of married life. Actually, I thought then that we had a good marriage and got along really well.

In retrospect, I wonder if it was a good relationship at all. If the foundation was really strong, then why did things crumble and fall merely because we had a problem? This question still lingers and consumes an endless amount of my time and energy.

My story is not any different than many other women. Recently my sister asked me, "What went wrong?"

I was blindsided by this question since she had been a witness to all the incidents and it has been three years since my husband walked out of the door with his family, to live on his own. I wondered why she had asked me that question, what was the real question.

The psychological landslide triggered by that question brought back the time when my husband banged like a maniac on the bathroom door where I had retreated to take a shower before going to work. When I came out, his clenched fists punched me in the ribs and sides, all while my mother-in-law looked on. At one point she did try to intervene and I tried to hit my husband back. I managed to hit him in the face in self-defense. He threw me to the sofa, sat on me and again used his fists. I don't remember the punches as much as the words that came out of my mother-in-law's mouth.

She said: "jaa, jithay tu jaana tu jaa, saada kherra chhudd!" (go wherever it is you want to go, leave us alone).

At that moment I realized that I would never be treated with respect or with fairness by this woman. Hadn't she just witnessed her son beating his wife and she was taunting me to call the police? A clever woman she is. After all, she had been the one to goad her son into assaulting me in the first place. She knew exactly which buttons to push and which suggestions to make to ensure that her son did as she asked. All along she knew what she was doing.

The funny thing is that she gets up at amrit vela to do paatth and visits the gurdwara each morning and prides herself as being a gursikh.

I left home for a few days with my children. Well, actually, I was forced to leave. When I returned, I went upstairs to hug my mother-in-law. She sat with a stone-face, and did not reciprocate nor say a word.

On a previous occasion, I had touched both my mother-in-law's and my father-in-law's feet because of a perceived slight.They had said I was being mouthy, I accepted my mistake, not knowing at the time that this was a family which was used to exaggerating and making small things overly dramatic. I also dismissed it because they were still new to the country and did not understand the forthright nature of those who grew up here.

These days, my mother-in-law has been encouraging her son to get a divorce and get married again. Rather than encouraging him to work at healing the wounds To this day, she still insists that she does not know what went wrong in our marriage and that she had she herself had nothing to do with it. 

I can't say that my own family, my flesh and blood, made it any easier for me. I was expected to do as told, to suck it up and do whatever it took to keep the family intact. I tried to do that for seven years, keeping resentment at bay while sacrificing my health and well-being.

I remember dreading the very thought of going home after work, because for me it symbolized a battleground with the lines clearly demarcating my husband's position in favour of his family. The drives home from work were unpleasant;  I began to suffer from panic attacks and, once home, I would be angry and fearful all at the same time. A home is supposed to be a sanctuary, a place where one goes to find solace and respite during times of suffering. Even the thought of going home to my two little girls could not keep those feelings at bay.

I work in the post secondary education field and am blessed to have to two solid months of vacation time in the summer.

However during the dark days, my vacation time was a curse. I continued to look for a way and a place to escape to. Many times I would leave work early and go to my parent's house to find some comfort in their home. I would immediately take a two-hour nap. Now I know that it was a sign of depression.

I told my parents little of what was going on at home at the time. I did not want them to worry and I felt I could deal with things on my own. I am sure they knew I wasn't doing well. My dad turned a blind eye while my mother's questions burdened me with more worry rather than relief.

My family tried to brow-beat me into staying quiet, to not say anything, to ignore my mother-in-law's interference. Their justification was that every woman has to do this and that I owed it to my girls to keep the family together. They told me I was being selfish, that I was putting my emotions and needs before my children's.

While we do sacrifice many emotions and feelings for our children, it is very hard to minimize the feelings of sadness and unhappiness. Children are more perceptive to imbalance. They could sense that things were not right even though they may not have had the words to articulate them.

In the meantime, my life turned into a circus.

People who had no business being involved were offering their opinions. My family involved others; they said they were 'trying to help'. My mom's brother from England asked me if they could intervene. I was not sure because he had a rocky relationship with my mom and his insistence seemed a bit suspicious. I relented because of the pressure from my older sister and brother-in-law.

I now  regret this very much. Rather than finding a solution, he only wanted to gather ammunition to use against my mom, to fling sibling rivalries in her face.

He was the one who encouraged my husband to leave.

This was a blessing in disguise. In the past, my husband had been trying to get me to leave the house; he said he wanted to create room for his relatives who were soon to emigrate from India and did not want me to put up with the hassle. I remember driving around in the city looking for a place for the girls and I and wondering how things were going to unfold.

Four months later my husband left our home. While packing, my mother-in-law kept saying to her son: "kaaka, ah veeh lai kai   jaana ai, ah veeh lai kai jaana ai!" (son are we taking this, and we are taking this ...)

Rather than make an effort to prevent the break-up of the home, she taunted me and rubbed it in my face. Later she asked him to help one of her friends whose husband had died, while her son's own family was dying a death of its own that day.

Not once did she ask what was wrong, she never made an effort to keep the family intact. Instead it was all blamed on me and she was the innocent victim, just like the rest of the family. I remember her telling someone that when her son was born, it was written in his taveh (a Hindu custom) that he would have two marriages.

Useless to point out that these very practices are not condoned in Sikhi, but why even put the thought our there in the first place.

These days, my mother-in-law is suggesting to my husband to get a divorce and get married again (meanwhile my mom says don't ruin your children's lives by getting involved with someone else, try to get closer with the one who has been chosen for you).

I suppose that is my mother-in-law's way of exacting revenge - for what? -  to teach me a lesson. I wonder when all the paatth and prayer she does is going to take effect? You see, I have been wrong about one thing, I thought she was MY worst enemy but not so, somewhere in my husband's destiny it was written that his worst enemy would take shape on this earth, in this life, in the form of his own mother!

There are many success stories of couples with children who have remarried and live fulfilling lives. Another marriage is not the solution, neither for my husband nor me. It is up to the elders, in this case, his parents to make amends, because to this day they continue to deny that they were responsible nor do they admit to any wrong doing. Does a proper gurusikh not say sorry and ask for forgiveness? Does he not ask for the opportunity to make amends?

 

January 26, 2012

 

Conversation about this article

1: K.H. (U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 10:20 AM.

My heart goes out to you. I truly do understand. It's so-o hard to understand why a girl's parents in the Indian community tend to have a blindside for their daughter's pain. How much more pain do daughters have to go through to get help?

2: H. Singh (Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 10:46 AM.

Dear A: Once a man hits you, it is time to get out. Your young daughters should not be witness to this abuse. I know too well how some so-called "god-fearing gursikhs" always blame the woman. Be strong. It will liberate you. Make your daughters strong by showing them what is and is not acceptable. You and they are blessed to live in a broader culture that can provide you support. Your family will never be able to accept a divorce, but you do what's right for you. And don't ever think there won't be someone else. But heal first and when you're ready, someone who is right for you will find you. My prayers are with you.

3: Manjit Kaur (Maryland, U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 11:21 AM.

Dear A. Kaur: I totally agree with comment #2. My prayers are with you. There are so many wrongs in this story but sadly the ignorant can't see that. You are blessed with a higher vision of truth. I'm sorry to say this but in 10 years down the road this will be a blessing in disguise. I too have been there - more than a decade ago - exactly the same story, but now, I am the happiest of persons.

4: Birendar Singh  (New Delhi, India), January 26, 2012, 11:44 AM.

There ought to be a law - a clear criminal offence - dealing with parents who ruin their children's lives like this and brutalize their daughters-in-law. Sure, there are two sides to each story, but I'm afraid this saga is a common one and, more often than not, the blame lies with such parents. My heart goes out to you, beta ... you'll be fine, I promise you. You have taken the first step ... that is, by having gone public with your pain, instead of letting it fester inside you.

5: H.S. Vachoa (U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 12:35 PM.

Ms Kaur: I commend you for writing this piece. You would be doing yourself a disservice to believe that such people like your husband, your family and your mother-in-law can ever change. Therefore, stop thinking about it. Such people are sadistic and narcissist. You need to concentrate on looking after yourself and your two beautiful daughters.

6: Harinder (Uttar Pradesh, India), January 26, 2012, 1:02 PM.

Have patience and faith, for this too shall pass.

7: Gurmeet Kaur (Atlanta, Georgia, U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 1:23 PM.

Many people will offer you advice. Ultimately, time will unfold what is best for you and your girls. As a person who's been through a similar story myself - my only request is, come what may, don't let your girls down. Be strong as an oak tree sheltering them. They will redeem you of all your agonies. I promise.

8: L.K. (Fresno, California, U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 2:08 PM.

Such a difficult story to read. I do agree that when in-laws show up, the playing field does become very different in the household. I have experienced some of what you have written. I was the son whose mother was just being stupid and playing games and I did realize all of this and we separated. It was very difficult and I felt so much pain for my wife and I could never figure out what my mother's problem was. Why did she need to cause trouble for nothing? Why did she need to break apart the family for nothing? - these are all the games of our karam and the attachment which gurbani talks about. It really does leave a bad taste in your mouth. I found myself at times having to choose between family and wife and it was really frustrating at times. I really felt angry at my family and, at times, my wife. Just didn't know what to do. On top of that, we were going through a financial crisis. My father was paralyzed and my mother was the sole care-giver. I felt so bad and frustrated and didn't know what to do. Eventually, I had to shift my parents to a new place for two years. Recently, we have made them a separate portion in the home (in-law suite) and we all keep our distance from each other. The thing is, elders and parents are not always right and do not always do things for your benefit; I really learned that the hard way. Joint families only work when everybody in the family is ready and willing to make sacrifices to keep the family together. It is very difficult these days. I found myself doubting everything in life - people, job, gurbani and God and at times feel as if I am lost - to this day. I felt so ignored by God and helpless. I still do feel the same way these days, sometimes it gets better and sometimes not. A. Kaur, I hope you are doing better now, this happens to many people, hope you come through it okay.

9: Madan Singh (Paris, France), January 26, 2012, 3:10 PM.

Re Comment # 8: L.K. ji - Though I sympathize with you and hope and pray that you will overcome this challenge with your own family intact, I am surprised that you are blaming God for something that your parents, you and your wife have joined hands in messing-up. I don't know your situation in detail and can't comment on it, but generally, I would think any sensible couple living in the West would be VERY, VERY CAREFUL about having in-laws move into one's household permanently without first having demarcated very clear boundaries. If you didn't, or your boundaries didn't work, don't blame God ... or fate or luck or the stars.

10: Bibek Singh (Jersey City, New Jersey, U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 3:22 PM.

"... dreading the very thought of going home after work", is the worst thing that can happen to someone. I have gone through it in my life, both when I was single and living with my friends, as well as in my married life. It is a very painful phase. The best way I could think and implement is to eventually 'agree to disagree' on certain aspects of our personalities, thought-processes & behaviour. It demands certain sacrifices to be made. However, in the long-run, we get used to living with those constraints. It is tough ... and makes you tougher. We would have fewer topics to discuss and talk about, but we would still talk. We would laugh together, but now on fewer occasions, but would still laugh and would still be together. It is a great challenge! The author rightly mentions - "... it is very hard to minimize the feelings of sadness and unhappiness". May your good old memories bring you (and your family) comfort at this moment! May you be able to re-unite!

11: Sukhi (U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 6:34 PM.

Dear A. Kaur: First and foremost, I commend you for writing this piece and sharing your story. To answer your question, "Does a proper gursikh not say sorry and ask for forgiveness? Does he not ask for the opportunity to make amends?" - In my opinion a considerate, compassionate human being would not only ask for forgiveness and would make amends but also take a step forward in telling others NOT to commit such atrocities to others; it's just not the Sikh thing to do. I can sense that there is a lot of hypocrisy and ego (negative one, not the positive) filled in that household. It's easy for me to say here that things will get better and it might be difficult for you to believe this, especially in times of pain, but I can vouch for one thing and that is: Time is a good healer and you will certainly grow. If you enjoy reading, I recommend Elizabeth Lesser's, "Broken Open: How Difficult Times Can Help Us Grow."

12: Sangat Singh (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia), January 26, 2012, 7:15 PM.

"Fareeda mai jaani-aa dukh mujh ioo dukh sabaa-i-aa jag/ oochay charh kai daykhi-aa taan ghar ghar ayhhoo ag" {GGS:1382.3] - "O Farid, I thought that I was in trouble, but the whole world is in trouble; when I climbed high and looked around, I saw this fire in each and every home". Challenges are everywhere in varying degrees. A. Kaur ji: if your problem is in the public domain, then show this piece to your husband. If only he could read it, he would realize that he will get away with it easily. But, to repair burnt bridges is not easy. Keep a foot in the door, and pray that good sense prevails.

13: A. Kaur (Canada), January 26, 2012, 8:41 PM.

Madan Singh ji. I agree with you that God does not create our problems, we are all complicit in the events that unfold in our lives. Some people are at less fault than others. However, when dealing with in-laws, it is like dealing with a corporate culture, it is very hard to make any measurable change. I do believe that the person we marry is not by sheer coincidence, these alliances are forged in heaven. We are also forced to deal with actions from a past life that carry forward into the present one. It's certainly not God's fault; it's the fruit of our own actions. I think this is what L.K. ji is referring to. Who else to blame but God, He is the only one who doesn't take it personally and never retaliates! The other part of my story is that my husband is less educated than myself and a couple of years younger. He was born and raised in a pind in India and came to Canada after we married. I never thought much of this at the time because compromises could be made. I was very naive! This created an imbalance in the relationship. Unfortunately, he is not an open minded 'Western' type, so it was expected that the in-laws would join us, that was never a choice. As new-weds he would often tell me if there were any problems when his parents moved from India, he would be on their side. Unfortunately, there was not much room for compromise.

14: Hari Singh (London, United Kingdom), January 26, 2012, 9:18 PM.

Dear A. Kaur ji: Many thanks for the courage to share such a painful part of your life with us; suffering of such acute mental nature, the constant emotional battering and the affliction of such a dreadful level of physical abuse by someone who you thought was the 'chosen one' for you, must be an unbelievable psychological blow on top of the externally visible physical wounds. The Guru intended marriage to be the merging of two souls! - not a relationship where blows are exchanged between the parties! I pray that Waheguru gives you the strength to face this trauma in a righteous and most appropriate manner ... in the gurmat way. As Sikhs, we believe that life is a challenge and the trick is to excel in life and to act in a fair and truthful way; to overcome our difficulties peacefully and amicably and live an honourable life based on high principles. Where your joint journey in marriage went wrong is a mystery; it is obvious that the journey was never of two souls walking closely together as intended by the Guru. It is clear that the love between the parties never got below the skin. As Sikhs we have to love down to the bones! When you get to that stage, then nothing can break down such a partnership. Regrettably, I do not believe that life afforded you this blessing! Probably in the fast western way, you too both got embroiled in the normal hustle and bustle of the material life that persists here without any thought for developing a deep spiritually loving relationship. Marriage is supposed to be a long journey, therefore full and thorough preparation is a must. You need to gather all the items to sustain you all the way on this long journey. The most valuable commodity on this journey is naam and surrender to it. However, nothing is lost yet. Climb back onto this train and you will overcome all your difficulties. Uttering gurbani without sipping its real essence is of little value. Sip this nectar so that the taste (the message) touches your heart. Only then will the docile become green again and life will open a new leaf. My prayers are with you and your beautiful children; may the sangat's joint ardaas and our love and deep plea to the Almighty reach your heart and re-ignite your life on a higher and better plane. Nanak naam chardi kalaa, tere bhane sarbat da bhala!

15: S. Singh (U.S.A.), January 26, 2012, 9:28 PM.

This story so mirrors my mother's story. For 35+ years she was constantly abused and harassed by my daadi (paternal grandmother) and father. Finally I took it upon myself to deal with the situation; as a result she does not stay with them anymore. But even today the harassement continues. I can only imagine how she lived like that for 35 odd years. She sacrificed her entire life so that I could have a good life. For that I am eternally grateful. My every success I owe to her. But if I could go back in time, I would have told her to move on. Pakhandies never change. Your mother-in-law will never change. My daadi to this day has not, nor has my father. I strongly suggest if you live in North America and can support your daughters, to move out and live on your own. No woman should be left at the mercy of others. It is so sad that all these people here are saying just carry on with this and pray. Why? Because A. Kaur is a woman? What if the situation was reversed and it was a man? It hardly would have been an issue. If you can live with the fact that for the next 25 years you will most probably not be happy and miserable, that is, till your kids leave for college, carry on with him. (BTW, if you are counting on your mother-in-law to die, that's not going to happen either. It never does. They have the longest lives. My daadi is still alive!) I've seen another person in my family who is currently going through the same abuse and harassement and she can't wait for it to be over when her children go to college. There you go - I just gave you two good examples of people and what happened to them for sticking around. I also want to ask all these people why should the mother sacrifice everything while the husband gets garam roti and daal when he comes home. Let that guy know what a great deal and a good woman he has lost in his life. MOVE OUT OF THAT PLACE!

16: A. Kaur (Canada), January 27, 2012, 10:28 AM.

S. Singh ji: I had a really good laugh when I read your point about waiting for the daadi to die. Yes, I had also been waiting for that, I must admit a bit sheepishly. Actually I have been living on my own for the past three years and am very involved in my daughter's lives. I have been blessed with two bright and confident girls. The problem is that it is hard to live in a neighbourhood where people I have known for many years like the opportunity to throw what they perceive as a failure on my part, in my face. This is where I have to do the mental work and spiritual work. Hari Singh so rightly stated everything that I have been feeling in that regard; it is time to get back on track and reunite with God. I would love to share this article with my husband but I would have more of a mess to clean up and would not be surprised if he retaliated and went to the Punjabi media. Thank you to everyone for your kind words of encouragement. I hope to write a second piece to provide a better context.

17: Roger Mangat (Merced, California, U.S.A.), January 27, 2012, 12:07 PM.

At the first hint of trouble, the author should have set the boundaries. If the in-laws crossed that line, alternative living arrangements should've been resorted to immediately. That's what I did when both of my parents crossed the line.

18: Harpreet Singh (Delhi, India), January 27, 2012, 1:58 PM.

Although I am a married man living with my wife, son and parents, many a time some misunderstanding does occur but never, ever turns physical or abusive. Actually, the intentions of all are good but the inability to understand the viewpoint of others or speaking rudely, is not uncommon in families. And if some bad moment is there, then to introspect and make amends is absolutely necessary, not just saying 'sorry'. One thing I have observed - we are often thankless. For example, it can be an ideal family, including the presence of elders, good children, job, house, health, everything ... so why quarrel? Think or talk with those who have no house, no income, no good health, no children or special-need family members, or some family member has been in a serious accident, or suffering from serious disease, etc. I know many such families. They cannot afford this luxury to indulge in spousal conflict or child abuse or mistreatment of in-laws, or even have time for gossiping or other useless things. I feel so sad to see such type of families here in Delhi also where Waheguru has given them every thing but they will always fight. Sadly, even parents of the couple wade in, without any care about the damage they do. But there are some good examples also. I think the local sangat knows of such cases and they should intervene when things go extreme. This aspect is missing now. Mature gurmukhs from the sangat should counsel such couples/families and guide them in accordance with Sikh principles. One couple known to us was counseled in detail by a gurmukh and they were able to stop their conflict. My sincere ardaas for all members of this family and others like them.

19: Inderjeet Kaur (U.S.A.), January 27, 2012, 6:53 PM.

First, on the practical side, I advocate that all our daughters learn self-defence. Then not only can they ward off physical attacks, but the attacjer will then be less likely to attack in the first place. Bullies are by definition cowards: they only abuse those who can't fight back effectively. Second, we need to encourage our daughters to get out and seek refuge with their parents, friends or other support groups, or get their own place the FIRST time they are hit, and make sure that there is no shame attached to their leaving thus. If she wishes to return to him, she shouldn't return until he and they have had counseling and the counselor is convinced he won't do it again. If he does it again, for her sake and for the children's sake, a divorce is necessary. All this goes to the ugly concept of izzat, and is another Indian concept we need to ditch completely. Beyond that, I am very proud of A. Kaur for having the courage to write this. Abuse within the family is such a taboo subject that it really needs to be brought out in the open. The life of no woman - especially a Sardarni - should be one of suffering brutality. Brutality does not have to be physical to offensive. Clearly the mother-in-law here is as much a bully as her spineless son. We all know how this works. She was bullied by her mother-in-law who had been bullied by her mother-in-law who had been bullied ... for generation after generation. Like other out-dated, destructive Indian customs, such as dowry and male preference in children, this needs to stop immediately.

20: Gurmeet Kaur (Atlanta, Georgia, U.S.A.), January 30, 2012, 10:40 AM.

I love all of what Inderjeet Kaur ji have to say. I couldn't have said it better.

21: Mimulynn (Sunnyvale, California, U.S.A.), February 09, 2012, 3:24 AM.

This is a very sad article and very upsetting, not only for the issues discussed and the violent nature of A. Kaur's story, but because even after she's gone through so much, she's still not asking herself the right questions nor fighting the right battle. If a man or his family mistreats you, if a husband is not mature enough to respect you or give you the place you deserve as his wife and companion, don't waste time blaming his parents or demanding an apology from them. They had nothing to do with his lack of respect for you, it's his responsibility and yours alone. It's up to women to demand respect from their partners, regardless of their culture. This article shows that A. Kaur is still anguishing over her husband leaving and her mother in law's betrayal, when she should be rebuilding her life and moving on to better times ahead. Ladies, self-love and self-respect are imperative in life, love yourselves, love your children, and have the courage to expect no less than the best treatment from your partners.

22: Harneet Kaur (Toronto, Ontario, Canada), March 04, 2012, 3:41 PM.

Miss Kaur, I'm so sorry for everything you have been through but there is One that can help you and that is God, who will always be on your side.

Comment on "Cri de Coeur:
A Cry From The Heart"









To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.