Kids Corner

Books

Khushwant Singh's Last Hurrah?

by KUMKUM CHADHA

 

 

THE SUNSET CLUB, by Khushwant Singh, Penguin/ Viking, India, 2010. Hardcover, pp 232. ISBN : 9780670085194. Rs. 399. 

 

 

The Sunset Club, declares Khushwant Singh, is his last novel.

One has heard this before, but he continues to release one book after another. And every time he does, it leads to traffic jams in Delhi. I remember how almost half of the capital turned up at the launch of his ‘last' book at a Delhi hotel.

Usually, it's someone of the stature of India's First Lady, Sardarni Gursharan Kaur, who releases the books Khushwant Singh authors. Ditto on Tuesday, November 30, 2010, when she will release The Sunset Club - Singh's last book, if he is to be believed.

"For God's sake, I am 96 (years)," he says.

On his part, Khushwant has lost count of the number of books he has written so far.

"Maybe a hundred, maybe more ... I don't know. Once [people from] the American Centre asked a similar question and I said I did not know. They fed my name into the computer and the book list generated was two yards long. After that also I wrote a few more books," he says.

Sunset ... Khushwant claims it is his best book too; fantasies of octogenarians, as he puts it. "What they cannot, do they imagine that they are doing," he says, summing up the novel as an "essay on love and lust".

The protagonists are three men: a Sikh, a Muslim and a Hindu. The first and last are based on real life characters: Khushwant himself and his friend Prem Kirpal, respectively. The third, a Muslim, is a combination of several people the author has known. The novel is based on notings from his dairy, which he has been meticulously maintaining for years.

"I put down everything from a cold to constipation to who came to see me," Khushwant says.

Set in the backdrop of picturesque Lodi Gardens, the novel begins on January 26, 2009, a Monday. It ends exactly a year later. By then, two of the three friends are dead. "Both Baig and Sharma had had good innings ... he is much the same age. His turn will come soon. When? No one knows," Khushwant Singh writes.

There is a passing reference to his telephone book and how against every second or third entry, he has written down the date of their deaths. "Against his own name he adds: D: date? month? year?"

That apart, there is an overdose of sex, vivid descriptions of lovemaking and Hindi equivalents of phallus, some clearly unmentionable. "In the case of males it is centred on the appendage in his middle. It goes through four stages of development all beginning with the letter L," he writes. But to call it a ‘book about sex' would be to oversimplify its intricate theme.

In fact, Khushwant extensively writes about the other most-read subjects: politics and politicians. Manmohan Singh, who "on his own ... would not have won a panchayat election"; Maneka Gandhi's launda (lad) Varun; Sonia Gandhi who knows "Indians won't accept an Italian-born woman as prime minister"; her son Rahul who is "too young and inexperienced ...,"  and more.

While referring to Najma Heptullah, Khushwant hits hard. He describes her as "... that fat woman from Bombay who claims to be a niece of Maulana Azad ... caught pedalling a false photograph ... no one trusts her." Then he writes about former Andhra Pradesh Governor N.D. Tiwari's sexploits; he celebrating Christmas with three women in bed and about his "bastard son". And, not to forget, about his own lady friend who is a shia Muslim, westernised, enjoys whiskey and mild flirtation but come Muharram, she wears black and has a majlis in her home at Jamia, Delhi.

Sunset ... has a bit of everything for everyone: religion, communal violence, the Babri masjid, our freedom struggle, Ghalib, Iqbal and even Tiger Woods and Nano. It's, Khushwant believes, his best book, but the one which he did not intend to write: "I had turned ninety five and was not sure I would be able to finish it," he writes at the outset.

 

[Courtesy: Hindustan Times]

November 27, 2010

 

Conversation about this article

1: Sangat Singh (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia), November 27, 2010, 11:01 AM.

Sheikh Chilli, the famous simpleton of yore and folklore was seen lying in a freshly dug grave and muttering to himself: "I was quite a useful man but now I am dead!" "But you are talking," exclaimed a passer by who overheard him. "Yes, I am freshly dead, and would continue to talk for at least another 24 hours." May you live, Khushwant, for another 24 YEARS and keep regaling us. Thanks for using the colourful "Khotey-aa" ... you helped resurrect a lot of people from the dead!

2: Gurjender Singh (Maryland, U.S.A.), November 28, 2010, 2:10 PM.

Khushwant Singh was the man who returned his Padam Shri award in protest against the Indian government's criminal assault on the Darbar Sahib in 1984.

3: N. Singh (Canada), November 28, 2010, 3:59 PM.

Yes, Gurjender Singh ji, but he was also the man who supported the Gandhi regime both before and after the attack on Darbar Sahib. He has written extensively about how Sikhism is part of Hinduism and thereby damaged the Sikhs' attempt to get their separate identity recognized. He has openly advocated that Bhindranwale was an 'terrorist' and 'evil' man and yet no one has been able to provide irrefutable proof of this. He was also a constant companion of K.P.S. Gill during the "counter-insurgency" years and urged him on to 'kill the bastards'. I am all for giving a person credit where credit is due but let us not skew the facts. This man has done untold damage to the Sikh identity and struggle for freedom and recognition. To this day, I have trouble understanding how and why he has any supporters!

4: Gagan Gupta (Bathinda, Punjab), November 29, 2010, 3:20 AM.

He is a real hero ... He'll always be in our hearts; we are all proud of him. Well done, Sir. May God always be with you!

5: Kirat Kaur (U.S.A.), November 29, 2010, 1:47 PM.

I agree 101% with N. Singh ji. He may be a good writer but his damage to his own community is irreparable.

6: Bibek Singh (Jersey City, U.S.A.), November 29, 2010, 5:16 PM.

In 2002, one of my friends gifted me Khushwant Singh's autobiography. I remember reading his interpretation of Sikhism, about his liking towards his maid, about his comments on the Punjab problem, etc. Although I did not like many of his comments, especially on Sikhism, yet we can pardon an author, as we all can have our own opinions on different topics. Having said that, I would like to highlight the following observation. Recently I was reading a book containing Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale's speeches. In a series of 4-5 speeches, delivered over three months from the Golden Temple Complex, Bhindrawale mentioned that the Indian government is misleading the innocent public and is creating a rift between the two communities. He further added that if at all Indira Gandhi pledges to kill Sikhs on false charges, then he would like to highlight that Sikhs have also figured out that the Sikh versus Hindu ratio is just 1 over 32. In his long speech(es), he mentioned that Sikhs know how to protect their honour and are always ready to fight on a 'sava lakh' basis (1 Sikh: 125,000 ordinary people) if need be. To me it did not appear to be a hate speech. Whereas, Khushwant Singh in his autobiography has mentioned this entire episode in his own flavour. He just mentioned that Bhindrawale was a criminal and an evil man who used to influence every Sikh to pick up arms to kill at least 32 Hindus. I am not sure whether this was written under any sort of pressure from the government or not. But it is certainly an unpardonable offense. An author can have his/ her own opinion about a subject or a personality, but should never distort facts especially on such sensitive topics. May he live long so that he gets time to correct such mistakes.

7: Kanwarjeet Singh (Franklin Park, New Jersey, U.S.A.), December 01, 2010, 12:42 PM.

What summed up Khushwant Singh for me was the interview he gave about M.K. GAndhi on Indian TV about a decade ago - he was asked on his views about Gandhi and he said "He (Gandhi) was a great man, I consider him higher than my Sikh Gurus". (Do note that no one had asked him to relate the man to any of the Sikh Gurus). Let us dig a bit into his history and see how adamant a supporter he was of his friend 'Mrs. Gandhi'. If we agree with him that Bhindranwale was evil and a criminal, then what would that make Indira?

Comment on "Khushwant Singh's Last Hurrah?"









To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.