Kids Corner


‘If We Don’t Talk About Our History, Who Will?’
A New Film About The Survivors Of 1984







Teenaa Kaur Pasricha’s ‘1984, When The Sun Didn’t Rise’ revisits the aftermath of the Delhi 1984 anti-Sikh pogrom that followed the execution of Indira Gandhi by two members of the country’s elite security sworn to defend its constitution.

When Teenaa Kaur Pasricha first read about the anti-Sikh genocide that began on October 31, 1984 and spread across the length and breadth of India, she was struck by the lack of awareness about its aftermath.

“I was devastated when I read about 1984, and the biggest question to me was: Why has there been no film on this subject?” Teenaa says. “If we don’t talk about our history, then who else will?”

Teenaa was particularly moved by the thought of the women who lost their husbands and homes in the violence. “I wondered how they came out of their trauma and started healing and negotiating with daily life,” she said.

She decided to address this paucity of narratives with her documentary 1984, When The Sun Didn’t Rise. The 57-minute documentary chronicles the lives of women who live in Delhi’s Widow Colony, which houses the widows of the Sikh men who were murdered in the pogrom in 1984 which continued for four days in the country‘s capital while the authorities refused to intervene.

The documentary took five years to produce, and was partially funded by Busan International Film Festival’s Asian Network and Documentary Fund, and Leipzig International Festival for Documentary and Animated Films’s fellowship titled Doc Wok. It was screened at the International Documentary and Short Film Festival of Kerala on June 18.

1984, When The Sun Didn’t Rise includes first-person accounts of women who lost their husbands, fathers, brothers and children in 1984, and are attempting to come to terms with their loss in different ways.

While one widow revisits the locality where her husband was killed, another makes peace with the idea that her missing husband could, in fact, be dead. Although the documentary incorporates other voices in the form of a legal expert and a politician from the ruling party who abetted the violence, the conversations with the women – with their paradoxical blend of vulnerability and resilience – remain the focus of the narrative.

Teenaa allows the widows to switch nimbly between Hindi and Punjabi while narrating their experiences, demonstrating that their grief is immune to boundaries of language. As we see the women engaged in their daily chores, it becomes evident that their linguistic flexibility is just one manifestation of the many adjustments they have made in order to fit into to a new milieu. But while women have adapted to make peace with the tragedy of their past, many men have succumbed to drug addiction.

The documentary also includes the story of a drug abuser to demonstrate how institutionalised drug addiction has eroded the emotional, mental and financial health of the vulnerable community, specifically its women.

“The challenge was finding someone who was a drug addict, and still open and honest enough to speak with me,” Teenaa said. “There was one person who was a drug addict, but he didn’t like my idea of coming to him, because the peddlers stopped giving him drugs. He just came up to me and said: you are not going to film me anymore. So I couldn’t do anything.”

Teenaa’s research process is reminiscent of ethnography, because she waited to be accepted by the community before capturing their everyday lives on camera.

“Every October 31, journalists come to interview these people and move on,” she observed. “And here I was, going to them again and again, listening to them. They were a bit surprised, because they hadn’t seen anyone coming to them so many times. The idea was to be a compassionate companion to them.”

She had to wait for 18 months to talk to one widow. “I had to sit outside her home, day after day, till she could actually trust me to tell her story.”

Since she continued to interact with the women for several years, Teenaa became emotionally invested in their stories. “I was just some girl listening to these stories and my heart used to cry,” she said.

Consequently, the documentary paints vividly painful portraits of trauma and grief, skillfully highlighting how personal tragedies affect political alliances.

1984, When The Sun Didn’t Rise highlights the trauma of the widows with unrelenting compassion and empathy. In one of the most poignant sequences, a group of widows is knitting together while they speak of the gruesome violence that surrounds the death of their husbands. As the camera focuses on a little boy listening to their conversation, it gently illustrates how the violence that has marred the life of his predecessors is still as much a part of the boy’s everyday life as the toy in his hand.

Teenaa Kaur hopes that her work will shed new light on a chapter of history wilfully neglected by an entire nation and provide the survivors with a measure of peace.

“I know that there will be no justice for these women,” she said. “My research revealed that to me. The only atonement is for the government to recognise that this was a state-planned massacre that took place for four days, not riots.”

1984, When The Sun Didn’t Rise was made with the intention to encourage people of different communities to become more tolerant of each other.

“When I was making the film, I felt terribly sad, because there is still discrimination happening,” Teenaa said. “Negros, dalits are still tortured in our country. We really need to know and accommodate each other, in the name of humanity.”

[Courtesy: Scroll. Edited for]
June 19, 2017

Conversation about this article

Comment on "‘If We Don’t Talk About Our History, Who Will?’
A New Film About The Survivors Of 1984"

To help us distinguish between comments submitted by individuals and those automatically entered by software robots, please complete the following.

Please note: your email address will not be shown on the site, this is for contact and follow-up purposes only. All information will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. Sikhchic reserves the right to edit or remove content at any time.